Scratch and Dent Thoughts from Nom De Plumber

 

First read this.

Scratch(ed) and Dent(ed) RMBS – Posted by Tracy Alloway – Here’s something that might have escaped your radar during Christmas week — a mass downgrade of so-called `Scratch and Dent’ RMBS deals by ratings agency FitchFT Alphaville

Here are additional thoughts from MNC reader, Nom De Plumber …

Implications, especially for whole-loan portfolios:

1.  Seasoned cohorts have been converging with newer cohorts, as negative equity and strategic borrower behavior trump all.  

2.  Seasoned mortgages are really just failed extensions/modifications.

3.  Cure rates for even seasoned mortgages will continue to decline – meaning that 30-day delinquencies are increasingly just inevitable defaults.

4.  Historical roll-rate default modeling is an insufficient credit predictor, as economic policies create incentives for borrowers to game for cheap or free home usage.

5.  Scratch-and-dent loans should be priced heuristically per observable severities, not econometric projections of eventual re-performance or refinancing/sale prepayments.

Nom De Plumber is a Nom De Plume.