Cynthia Koehler is Senior Attorney and California Water Legislative Director for EDF.
This weekend’s Celebration of the Life of Tom Graff at the Scottish Rite Temple in Oakland was all that one might imagine. Hundreds of Tom’s friends, family, fans, colleagues old and new came together to share favorite stories, fond memories, laughs and of course a tear or two, or more, for California’s foremost eco-Godfather (or Delta Force, as a legal rag once notably labeled Tom). Looking out over the standing-room only crowd filled with public officials, water agency folk, enviros and so many friends, it was impossible not to be struck by Tom’s extraordinary reach and breadth.
Speaker after speaker noted not only Tom’s braininess, strategic acumen, and analytical skill but also and more critically, the man’s fundamental humanity, his graciousness, kindness, unfailing humor, love of life, family and his fundamental regard for people of all stripes. Not merely an ardent and effective “lawyer for fish,” Tom was a listener, a teacher, the one in the room who could find the way to ‘yes’ without compromising integrity or principle.
My own association with Tom began more than 20 years ago in a courtroom presided over by a massive pink plastic salmon hung on the wall by a judge determined to keep the lawyers’ collective eyes on the prize. That trial resulted in the famous Hodge flows to protect salmon on the Lower American River, and marked a turning point in California’s water history. The recent Delta legislation may well prove to be another such turning point, and was an effort that Tom followed with intense interest.
In our conversations about the bill’s progress over the course of the summer and fall, Tom’s focus – just like all those years ago on the American River — was on the public trust flows, the eco-requirements of the natural world and how to most effectively assure them over time. Certainly Tom did not support the water bond, and was disappointed (as were we all) when the beneficiary pays and fee provisions were excised from the package. But he was quite pleased that through all of the negotiations the bill retained the provision directing the SWRCB to determine the Delta’s public trust needs, and he exhorted us to retain the primacy of the public trust, something the bill does explicitly.
Tom passed the morning that the Delta legislation was signed, and standing on the levee listening to the Governor give the first of what would be many tributes, it struck me that Tom’s reaction to the final product most likely would have been to grin and say, with his trademark twinkle, “Good job, but let’s get more next time.” Absolutely. Ensuring that the environmental promise of the Delta legislation becomes a reality is perhaps one of best legacies we can strive for in the wake of this extraordinary man