Sugar Ray Frontman Mark McGrath & Girlfriend Expecting Twins

Sugar Ray frontman and former Extra host Mark McGrath and his longtime fiancee Carin Kingsland are expecting twins. The couple tells PEOPLE Magazine that their son and daughter — conceived via in vitro fertilization — are due in May.

Although McGrath is nervous about bringing the babies home, he says he “can’t wait to meet them.” “I love them already, but I need them to come out so I can really shower them with love,” he added.

McGrath, 42 and Kingsland, 37, have been dating on and off for the past 16 years.