A Plea for Credit Score Transparency

Do you know what your credit score is? Sorry to trick you with a loaded question like that. Different credit bureaus come up with different algorithms leading to different numbers. The three major credit bureaus, Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion, could all give you different numbers. And to get those numbers you typically have to pay them.

If you are a bit frugal with your cash, there are cheaper options. For instance, thanks to some great legislation you can go to AnnualCreditReport.com and request to view your credit report from each of the three major credit unions. It’s important to note that this is just a credit report – not a credit score. You get the information that they are pouring into Fair Isaac Company’s Black Box (FICBB), but not the number the box spits out. Alternatively, you can get a free score of TransUnion’s data from Credit Karma. The catch there is that Credit Karma’s black box is not the same as FICBB. I’ve found it to be fairly accurate for me, but there is no guarantee that is similar for everyone.

I suppose you are thinking, “Yeah, great… so what?” I’m uncomfortable not knowing exactly how that FICBB works. While there are numerous hints and tips on how to fix your credit the process for calculating the score isn’t as transparent as it could be. We don’t really know what’s going on in the FICBB.

Now you may be thinking, “What do we gain from a transparent credit scoring system? I’ve done fairly well with the current system.” Our credit scores impact our finances greatly. Our finances impact our quality of life. I think we have the opportunity to make our credit scoring system more accurate. That will only help people with money to lend figure out who is a good credit risk. We’ll only find out if we open up the FICBB or develop another system that consumers can examine. Then, like open source software, we can look for holes in the credit scoring system and fix them. The overall product will be stronger because of it.

Maybe someday a company (perhaps Credit Karma) will this vision to reality. Perhaps a company already has and it’s not on my radar. What do you think? Leave me a comment

Related posts:

  1. Free Credit Scores from Credit Karma – No Scam Credit Karma is no scam If you are looking for…
  2. Credit Karma’s Credit Simulator (and Other Credit Tools) Last April, I went to Finovate Startup in San Francisco….
  3. Hack Your Credit Score? When I was at Prosper’s annual conference, CEO Chris Larsen…
  4. Mailbag: Hacking your credit score, Too Much P2P, and Giving Away $150 One of my favorite sports writers, Bill Simmons blends humor,…
  5. Credit Card Arbitrage I’m not one to believe in fate or signs, but…