Martin Bosworth has written up a longish post discussing what he calls “The Creative Class War.” It’s an interesting read that hits on a lot of different points, many of which I agree with, and a few I don’t agree with, but it’s worth reading anyway, if only to be horrified by the news of a novel that apparently spends a few chapters following an “intellectual-property enforcer who literally tortures and dissects copyright infringers to death.” Yikes.
There’s too much in the post to respond to each of the points — either the ones I agree with or disagree with — but there was one concept that is part of the root of the argument which I simply don’t believe is true, even though I’ve heard others say it as well. It’s the idea that the views held by many people criticizing rights holders for being overly aggressive in enforcing their rights comes from some sort of “resentment” of content creators. Bosworth notes:
There’s a long-simmering resentment of people that actually make art, and the Internet has brought it to the surface in a way we’ve never seen before.
I have to say that I just don’t see this. It’s an argument we’ve seen thrown out by various people who disagree with us at times (“you just say that because you’ve never created anything of value in your life!”) but it doesn’t ring true at all. First of all, many of us who fall on the side of often being critical of overly aggressive copyright enforcement are critical because we think that it will backfire and harm those that the law is supposed to “protect.” The point of highlighting why it’s a bad idea isn’t that we resent those who did something creative, but because we want to see them succeed and making an anti-fan, anti-consumer decision will make that more difficult. It’s not resentment at all.
Coming at the same question from the other direction, again, I have trouble seeing “resentment” as the issue at all. When we look at the success stories, the one thing that comes through loud and clear is that respecting fans results in those fans becoming incredibly loyal. They’re loyal to a fault, in fact. There’s no resentment there at all. If anything, at times, it seems to border on hero worship.
I’m not denying that there is some resentment out there of successful people. There are always some people who are resentful of others, but I just don’t see that as a driving force in the criticism of content creators who choose a path that is anti-fan.
Update: Wow. So it turns out that Martin, who wrote the post above and sent it to me on Tuesday (and promised to write more on the subject) actually passed away on Wednesday. I’m really sorry to hear that. Very tragic.
Permalink | Comments | Email This Story
