Author: Anna Keshelashvili

  • Georgia: Mock news report causes panic

    Crossed out logo of the channel

    Crossed out logo of the channel

    On Saturday 13 March, the Imedi national television broadcaster aired a mock news report stating that Russian tanks had invaded Georgia and that the president was dead. Aired at 8pm, the usual time slot for daily news, the nation's most trusted broadcaster (according to the last year's study by Caucasus Research Resource Center) offered its audience the worst possible case scenario of what might happen a week after municipal elections scheduled for the end of May in the country's capital, Tbilisi.

    According to that scenario, the opposition might seize power and turn the country into a confederation and ally of Russia. Moreover, some Georgian troops decide not to defend President Saakashvili and instead back the opposition's temporary government. The visuals accompanying the mock report, as well as the anchor of the program, were exactly the same as of that for a regular newscast, aside from a brief introduction informing viewers that what followed was a simulation of possible events.

    2E15F01F-7356-482A-86D1-92145A2C61F1_w527_s

    Screen shot of mock report on Imedi television – RFE/RL

    However, using footage from the August 2008 war with Russia presented in the format of a regular news program caused momentary panic in the country. “Requiem of the Georgian Dream,” as the producers called it, detailed an apocalyptic end to democracy in Georgia after opposition leaders Nino Burjanadze and Zurab Noghaideli, who recently befriended Russia's President, take power.

    During the program, which lasted half an hour, some of those living in villages close to the conflict zone reportedly fled to nearby forests to escape what they believed were advancing Russian troops, while shocked people called for emergency help, lined up at grocery stores and ATMs, and cars queued at petrol stations, concerned that recent history was repeating itself.

    The private company, which also broadcast the same program on radio,  violated the Code of Conduct for Broadcasters which says that reenactments should be avoided or at least clearly identified as such, while outraged citizens staged a protest in front of the TV station.

    One local blogger, Dodka was among the 300-500 people and posted updates on Facebook. Accused by some of being a provocateur because she said she was there to protest against Imedi's actions rather than support the opposition, she also posted some photographs.

    protest in front of Imedi TV

    Protest in front of Imedi TV by Dodka

    ოპოზიციამ, რა თქმა უნდა, შანსი ხელიდან არ გაუშვა და უხვად წარმოგვიდგა, ასე ვთქვათ. თუმცა მთავარი ფიგურა ბურჯანაძე იყო. ჩემი მეგობარი, რომელიც იქ დამხვდა, საერთოდ გამოეცალა და ცდილობდა მოშორებით დამდგარიყო, მაგ ქალის გვერდით არ ვიქნებიო.

    The opposition, of course, didn't miss a chance and was represented by many faces. But the main figure was Burjanadze. A friend of mine, whom I met there, was trying to avoid the crowd by standing a bit further away not wanting to stand by “that woman.”

    Other people also went online to vent their anger. One of the first reactions on blogs and Facebook came from Rocko in the form of an excerpt from the above mention broadcaster's code.

    • კრეატივი
    • პროფესიონალიზმი
    • ჟურნალისტობა
    • ეთიკა
    • ნორმები
    • გადაცემა „სპეციალური რეპორტაჟი“
    • მომავლის ხედვა
    Fuck your:

    • Creativity
    • Professionalism
    • Journalism
    • Ethics
    • Norms
    • Special Report
    • View on future

    Another blogger, Dv0rsky argued that behind the decision to broadcast the program lay with Giorgi Arveladze, Director of Imedi TV, and the ex-Minister of Economy as well as long time friend of the Georgian President, especially after a court in Gibraltar ruled that Ina Gudavadze, widow of the former tycoon owner of Imedi, had the right to claim part of her husband's property, among them shares in the station.

    ადვილი მისახვედრია, რომ იმედის ჟურნალისტები არაფერ შუაში არიან დღევანდელ სიუჟეტთან – მათ მხოლოდ ის გააკეთეს, რაც დაავალეს. დამვალებელმა კი ძალიან კარგად იცოდა – თუ ტელევიზიას კარგავს და სხვას უნდა გადასცეს, მაშინ ჯერ ყველა ღონეს იხმარს და ჩაძირავს მას, შემდეგ კი მიატოვებს განწირულ ხომალდს.

    It's not hard to understand that Imedi TV journalists have nothing to do with today's program – they did what they were ordered to do. And he who gave this order knew very well that if he is losing a channel he will use any means to drown it before abandoning ship.

    Fazanda addressed a post to those who justified the decision to broadcast the program.

    მათ რომ ჰკითხო, თურმე ხალხს არ უნდა შეშინებოდა, რომ ეს შიში უფრო საგანგაშოა, რადგან არველაძემ ე.წ. Wake Up Call გაგვიკეთა და ამის გამო მას კი არ უნდა ვემდუროდეთ, არამედ გულებში უნდა ჩავიხედოთ თურმე.

    If you ask them, people shouldn't have been scared, that this fear is more alarming, because it was a wake-up call by Arveladze and instead of blaming him, we should be searching our souls.

    Other opinions were shared by Sweet, Zurrius, Tiny and Gabo, who were at the theater enjoying Shakespeare's Twelfth Night when the audience started to receive phone calls informing them of the imaginary invasion and death of the president. Actors stopped their performance, but returned after discovering the story was false. Back on stage they chatted with the few people left in the hall, and the lead gave some bloggers the title for their posts after he said that “theater is immortal.”

  • Georgia: Tragedy strikes as Winter Olympic Games open

    georgian team

    In perhaps the most emotional moment of the Opening Ceremony, the crowd rises to give the Georgian athletes, led by Alpine skier Iason Abramashvili, a standing ovation following the tragic death of 21 year old luge athlete Nodar Kumaritashvili earlier in the day. Photo ©s.yume (Licensed under Creative Commons)

    News about the tragic death of Georgian luger Nodar Kumaritashvili a few hours before the opening of the 2010 Winter Olympics in Vancouver, Canada, broke out just after midnight the same day on a Georgian forum. The 21-year-old  died when he lost control of the luge during training near the final turn of the track at over 140km/h (about 90mp/h), thrown over the protective wall and hit a steel support pole. Kumaritashvili was airlifted to hospital where he was pronounced dead.

    Several hours after the accident, Georgia's Olympic Team, wearing black scarves and armbands and carrying a flag with a black ribbon, was greeted with a standing ovation at the opening ceremony. Near the end of the ceremony, Kumaritashvili was honored with a minute's silence.

    Several Facebook groups and fan pages were created and joined by thousands of users who mostly expressing condolences to the family. Georgia's President Mikheil Saakashvili, who was in Canada for a two-day visit, met with seven-person Georgian Olympic team and also asking them to attend the opening ceremony. Minister of Sports and Culture, Nikoloz Rurua, also said that a new luge track to be opened in Bakuriani, Georgia, will be named after Nodar Kumaritashvili.

    Online, Twitter users commented on the tragedy.

    @DeCap69: They should give Nodar Kumaritashvili a posthumous gold medal… that would be the classy thing to do to remember a fallen athlete…

    Forums, as well as many international and Georgian media outlets, aired the footage of the tragic accident over and over again, outraging many and generating a large number of tweets.

    @15minutesstupid Should the television networks be airing the death of Olympian Luger Nodar Kumaritashvili http://www.15minutesofstupidity.com/

    When the International Luge Federation declared that the fatal accident was not caused by an “unsafe track”, but rather because of “human error,” users of the Georgian forum, many of whom were using Nodar Kumaritashvili's picture with RIP on it, were convinced of the opposite.

    werner-forum-quote

    I just looked carefully and if there weren't these steel poles, he would be alive now. He would get hurt, but wouldn't die if there was an empty space instead of those poles, or if they weren't so close to each other. The organizers' blunder caused the death of the guy. How can one be so irresponsible about someone's lives? Moreover, very experienced athletes had been badly hurt on that track. Shame on whoever built it.

    Many Twitter users also expressed doubts about the official explanation.

    @designspotnyc how can they blame the luger's death on inexperience? the articles i read yesterday prove that he was far from inexperienced. shame!

    @thoughtsonthis Olympic Track Didn't Cause Luger's Death ??? Yes it did!: http://digg.com/d31IhkD?t #Digg (Via @ tvvitter)

    google luger

    Even Google faced some criticism when a new logo on its search engine page depicted a lugar for almost a full day, causing confusion worldwide among users who were uncertain whether it was out of respect for the dead athlete, coincidental or simply in bad taste.

    @tara IMHO if Google is going to put a picture of a luger on their page, they should note respect to Nodar Kumaritashvili http://bit.ly/aGe4F3 #fb

    @lisarowan: Google's Olympic graphic today is a luger – intentional or had been planned? don't know whether to like the tribute or hate the irony

    Whether because of the confusion it created, criticism from many users online, or because of the time it took to design another logo, the logo was changed by the end of the day to a snowboarder. However, even that didn't go without comment on Twitter.

    @steverubel Google swaps today's Olympic doodle from luge to snowboarding. Good move. Why didn't they think of this yesterday

    RT @mashable: Our most retweeted post right now: “Google Pulls Olympic Luge Logo After Backlash” – http://bit.ly/d6ffKC