Author: Michael David White

  • Realtors Say The Housing Fall Is Over, While Inventory Approaches Peak Crash Levels

    New Observations estimates excess inventory for sale equals 1.4 million units with over 4-million homes on-the-block, a figure hovering just 11 percent below peak-crash inventory, while at the very same time the realtors’ chief economist forecast Monday that “the housing price correction appears essentially over.”

    A respectable 521,000 units sold in April, yet inventory for sale increased by 418,000 units. On average inventory is 2.66 million units and currently 4.04 million homes are for-sale (Please see the chart below of units for sale. The red line represents an average. Click image for a large view.).

    mdw charts 5/25

    Inventory increased to 8.4 months of supply versus the long-run average of 5.8 months and the recent low of 6.5 months last November. The crash high inventory was 11.3 months in April 2008.

    mdw charts 5/25

    “Although inventory levels remain above normal and much of the gain last month was seasonal, the housing price correction appears essentially over,” said Lawrence Yun, chief economist for the National Association of Realtors (NAR). “In fact, a majority of the markets have seen price gains recently. A return to old-fashioned responsible lending and buying will help the housing market avoid disruptive and painful bubble-bust cycles.”

    mdw charts 5/25

    Last week the Mortgage Bankers Association said that a record 4.63 percent of homes are in foreclosure. Foreclosures are a major contributor to falling prices.

    On the positive side of the ledger, interest rates are outstanding right now and affordability has dramatically improved following a 30 percent national loss in home prices which started four years ago.

    The national median existing-home price was $173,100 in April, up 4.0 percent from April 2009. Distressed sales accounted for 33 percent of the total and all-cash sales clocked in at 250 percent of their normal tally.

    “Buyers are focused on finding the right house and taking advantage of favorable affordability conditions,” said Vicki Cox Golder, NAR president and owner of Vicki L. Cox & Associates. “For many buyers, owning a home is a lifestyle choice. They want a place of their own to raise a family, build memories, and be part of a larger community.”

    Nearly 10 percent of current mortgage borrowers are seriously delinquent, being 90-days late or more. New Observations estimated last week that a minimum of one in ten mortgage borrowers will lose their home to the bank in a distressed sale or foreclosure in the next two years.

    Our real estate market rests on a razor’s edge. On the edge lie high mortgage delinquencies, 12 million homeowners who have no equity or negative equity, high unemployment stuck at 10 percent, an unprecedented loss in house values following a bubble greater by far than any in the last 120 years, and a frightened Fed and Treasury who literally own the new mortgage market in the United States. Predicting that we are done with falling prices may end up landing the speaker north of reckless. Desperation hides behind a mask of confidence.

    Join the conversation about this story »

  • 13 Reasons You Should Sell Your House Now Before It’s Too Late

    detroit demolitionLast quarter we posted 12 Charts You MUST See Before You Even Think About Buying A Home.

    Contrarian mortgage broker and editor of newobservations.net, Michael David White has given us the latest picture on these scary charts. The housing market is more precarious than ever. That’s why you should rent, not buy. And if you’re thinking about selling, don’t wait another day.

    Here are the scary charts >

    Yes, home affordability has improved a lot, but…

    Yes, home affordability has improved a lot, but...

    Inventory is still very high

    Inventory is still very high

    Housing supply is picking back up

    Housing supply is picking back up

    Delinquent mortgages are high… and could lead to a huge property influx

    Delinquent mortgages are high... and could lead to a huge property influx

    There’s still a huge mortgage mess

    There's still a huge mortgage mess

    Underwater mortgages are the ten-ton gorilla

    Underwater mortgages are the ten-ton gorilla

    15% of borrowers are 30‐days late or worse. The cure rate at 60‐days late is almost zero.

    15% of borrowers are 30‐days late or worse. The cure rate at 60‐days late is almost zero.

    History says property value will fall through 2012

    History says property value will fall through 2012

    We assume prices will return to the 100-year FLATLINE

    We assume prices will return to the 100-year FLATLINE

    Based on four major indexes, prices have another 17% to fall

    Based on four major indexes, prices have another 17% to fall

    Housing bubbles were greater abroad… and have further to fall

    Housing bubbles were greater abroad... and have further to fall

    Rates WILL rise… and then real estate demand will fall

    Rates WILL rise... and then real estate demand will fall

    Considering massive government intervention, unit sales are frighteningly low

    Considering massive government intervention, unit sales are frighteningly low

    Don’t miss…

    Don't miss...

    Image: Zillow

    Join the conversation about this story »

  • Why Your Home Will Lose 13% Of Its Value In 2010

    (This is a guest post by Michael White, editor of newobservations.net and a mortgage broker.)

    The New Observations quarterly forecast of property values estimates a loss in values this year of 13 percent – a slight uptick from the 12% loss forecast at the beginning of the year.

    The average of four major nationwide indexes measuring prices also continues to suggest we hover right around a middle point of the total loss expected. Our current loss by the average of four indexes from the peak in 2006/2007 is 20 percent. The total loss forecast by the blend of indexes is 33 percent.

    mdw 13%

    The losses for this year projected in the four indexes vary widely and range between 3 percent and 24 percent. The indexes predicting large losses this year are biased by quicker and deeper losses which they registered following the peak. The variance between the indexes is demonstrated by a tally of current losses: It is only nine percent according to the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), but it is 30 percent at Case Shiller.

    A chart of all four data sets follows.

    mdw 13%mdw 13%

    mdw 13%mdw 13%

    Join the conversation about this story »

  • Why Your House Will Lose 12% Of Its Value In 2010

    Michael David White is a mortgage broker in Chicago and a real estate pundit. This article appeared on his Web site, newobservations.net.

    NewObservations.net projects residential real estate prices will fall 12 percent nationwide in 2010.

    Our average of four major indexes predicts a total fall in prices of 34% from peak to stable trend. The total fall of 34% is based upon a current loss across four number sets of 19%.

    The timing and the total fall vary widely among the data. The most conservative picture of our total fall is a 20% loss. The most radical prediction is that values will fall 51% from peak to stable trend (Please see the summary of results immediately below.).mdw charts

    One data set predicts that we will attain a trend value this year and then push beyond it (See below the First American Core Logic Chart.). The projections provided here artificially limit the loss to a return-to-trend value.mdw chartsTwo conservative data sets see the fall in values continuing through the summer of 2013. If correct, that’s equal to 3.5 more years of falling prices. The leading economic historians say prices normally fall for six years after a credit bubble. Based upon a summer 2006 high, the middle of 2012 is the projected bottom (Please see the chart below from CARMEN M. REINHART and KENNETH S. ROGOFF.).mdw charts

    All of the forecasts here are based upon the author’s assumption that real estate is a stable investment which largely tracks inflation. The follow-on assumption is that values broke out of this stable pricing pattern in a real estate bubble which started in 1990.

    The basis of the primary assumption, the assumption that real estate is a stable non-appreciating asset, is taken directly from Robert Shiller. He is a leading expert on real estate prices.

    “My data show that between 1890 and 1990 real home prices actually didn’t increase,” Mr. Shiller wrote in Newsweek (Dec 30, 2009), Why We’ll Always Have More Money Than Sense. If prices didn’t appreciate for 100 years, it leads one to assume the break in that pattern is an artificial break.

    The prediction of a 12% fall this year averages forecasts ranging as high as 28% and as low as 4%. I try to make no judgment about these estimates. I report the numbers objectively based upon providing a linear projection of the fall in prices dating from the market peak. Each data set is treated the same way. If the upward trend starting in 1990 is supportable and real, then the numbers provided here are very likely to be incorrect. If government policies reenact a bubble, these numbers will also be incorrect.mdw chartsmdw charts

    The federal government has taken extraordinary measures to stop the fall predicted by these trend charts. Given the massive power of the United States Treasury and the Federal Reserve, those efforts may win. Their steps to artificially maintain prices center on Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the FHA making essentially every new mortgage loan in the United States today.

    Without their lending, real estate prices in the United States would fall dramatically. The author estimates prices would fall 50% to 75% from today’s level if Fannie, Freddie, and the FHA stopped making loans. Private investment in mortgage loans has disappeared. Without government lending most purchases would have to be made from the buyer’s savings. Buyers would have to pay all cash. It’s a way of doing things we don’t even understand.

    We are in a radical real estate depression hidden from us by massive government fixes.mdw charts

    In a November 2009 report I estimated total excessive mortgage issuance of $5 trillion – Losses and Zombie Debt in Residential Mortgages Surpass $5 trillion (See the chart above.).

    ***

    Given that the most essential element of our competitiveness is based upon the cost of labor, and given that the price of housing is our most expensive cost of living, we cannot live well, compete in the global marketplace, and pay for bubble-priced real estate all at the same time. We have to make a very difficult decision.

    The smartest conclusion is obvious. Our highest priority must be to bring down the house of cards. We should encourage foreclosures. We should encourage default. We should bring overhead down. Our first goal must be inexpensive housing. (See Mortgage Default is a Patriotic Duty.)mdw charts

    The most provocative of all of the charts which I have been studying in the last six months suggests the fall is inevitable. All of the government maneuvers will fail because delinquent first mortgages are now equal in number to three times a balanced for-sale inventory (Please see above “Delinquent Mortgages: Will They Overwhelm Supply?”).

    My prediction is that the leaders at our Treasury and the Fed will finish as the bigger or the biggest fools. They are waging nuclear war to maintain bubble pricing on 129 million housing units (If you are like me, you say that sentence, and you know that the policy is dead wrong.). Only an academic bureaucrat could make such a choice and believe in it. And the financial press has not even one word to say against this lunatic fantasy. The blind cover the dumb and vice versa.

    Ben Bernanke and Timothy Geithner prove that book learning makes you dumb and government work makes you slow. Don’t put your faith in them or their experience. They haven’t spent enough time in the real world.

    If you own real estate and you can sell, sell it. If you want to buy, make sure you are staying for 10 years and insist on a great deal. Make sure you can live with losing 10 percent or 20 percent or 30 percent of the price that you pay for your home.

    The risk inherent in our current real estate market is far beyond the tolerance of 98% of would-be buyers. That means you. You can get screwed badly if you buy now. Don’t do it. Don’t put yourself in the poor house.

    ***

    Click here for more notes and data on the forecast. Please send your suggestions and corrections. If you have a better way of projecting the fall, please email me. I will send the Excel file for you to re-work and then publish your findings. [email protected]mdw charts

     

     

    Join the conversation about this story »

    See Also: