The reaction on the James Toney signing has been mixed in the United States. Many of you think it’s a good promotional move and if matched correctly Toney has a shot to do a little damage. Matched incorrectly, against a Randy Couture, and the old boxer may get destroyed and embarrassed because of a lack of takedown defense and grappling skills. Gareth A. Davies, who covers MMA for the U.K.’s Telegraph and serves as an insider on ESPN.com’s MMA Live, hates the Toney signing across the board.
I thought it was ridiculous then, I still think so. Toney is out of shape, has no MMA experience, and is two steps down from the signing of Kimbo Slice last year. Yes, Slice drew viewing figures, but don’t expect him to be anywhere on the landscape 12 months from now.
A strong take by Davies. The problem is that he contradicts himself by describing the exact scenario that makes Toney intriguing and one that will open lines of debate for months.
Toney, 41, has a 72-6-3 (2 no contests) record that includes 44 wins by knockout. I reckon they’ll look to match him with the likes of Randy Couture … trouble is he could knock Couture out.
Why is that trouble? It makes for a great promotion. Sounds like our buddy Gareth is so much of an MMA convert, that he’s now interested in protecting the sport. Come on G!
The discussion in the Telegraph’s comment section backs up why the UFC rolled the dice on Toney.
Commenter Adabesi:
With the money going out of boxing it is only a matter of time before a boxer goes into MMA and becomes a champion. They have great hands and chins which is something almost everyone in MMA doesn’t have.
Signing Toney just opens up the gates for the other boxers to come into MMA and it is a great move by the UFC. We have been asking the question of what will happen when a great boxer gets in the ring since Royce first won UFC 1, it is time to start finding out the answer.
Frankwongschippy:
Couldn’t agree more with you on Toney. Anyone know what that mma guy with no legs and hands is doing lately ? What about Muhammed Ali, now Dana could sell some tickets there!! Dana was ‘ambushed’? Jaysus, so now we know that every boxer/circus clown/wannabe ‘ardman can ‘ambush’ and harass the president of a billion dollar organisation called the UFC and potentially get a fight ? Dana should just admit that it was based on preventing ‘Strikeforce’ getting him and he can make some money out of it at the same time.
MMASuperfan:




Bowles, 29,
Dominick Cruz has a great head on his shoulders. He’s a crafty guy who stuck to his game plan of movement and fakes. Apparently, his head is made of granite, too. When Brian Bowles could actually catch him, the former WEC bantamweight champ landed a few big shots. But it hurt him more than Cruz. On the doctor’s advice, Bowles couldn’t come out for the third round because of a badly injured right hand, giving the 24-year-old Cruz his first world title via TKO stoppage in the main at WEC 47 in Columbus, Ohio.
There’s nothing left to say to Jens Pulver after his latest loss. His fall from the elite has been sad and has happened very much in the public eye. Sure, he’s only 35, but Pulver has been passed by from a technique standpoint and he’s less competitive with each passing fight.



Remember how many times Dana White has scoffed at the question about Strikeforce being competition? We’re about to confirm that the man was fibbing a bit. Showtime has pissed him off and CBS to a certain extent. It all started with the signing of Fedor Emelianenko and then Dan Henderson. Now White appears to be bringing out the big guns. Counter-progamming is one thing. A Spike UFC card across from a CBS Strikeforce card will severely damage the smaller promotion’s efforts to get things up and running. Now it looks like White is sending in the ground troops. The UFC is on the verge of locking down a fight card the same night in THE SAME CITY!
I think it is a business decision rather than a genuine, good signing.
I hope toney gets choked out, and I’m sure he will….. He will spend so much time on his back he will forget how to walk to his corner between rounds.