Nathaniel Tapley, an award-winning comedy writer, writes “Yesterday, I wrote a blog post disagreeing with [Bernie Corbett,] the General Secretary of my union, the Writers’ Guild of Great Britain, who was defending the Digital Economy Bill. Surprisingly, he emailed me with a full response, which I have now posted at the link above, and I’ve answered a couple of his points in the comments section. Anyway, I thought it might be of interest to some of your readers, as it’s a detailed response from a supporter of the Digital Economy Bill.”
Tapley joins the many creatives that oppose the Digital Economy Bill. His original post that spurred Bernie Corbett’s response is a worthwhile read, as is his response to Corbett’s email. Tapley’s main point of contention is that it is stupid to disconnect anyone if they are suspected of violating copyright:
Internet disconnection works directly against writers, musicians and artists being able to get their works in front of audiences, and paying audiences. In the last five years a number of models have emerged for ‘monetising content’ (ugh!) At present, the residuals and tips and ad revenues make up a small but growing part of many creators’ incomes, and more sophisticated models are being developed.Reducing the number of people who have access to my work is not the same as working on my behalf, Bernie.
It’s great to see more people come out of the woodwork who seem to understand how to approach new challenges as opportunities and not threats. That said, while it’s great that there is this discussion between people who disagree about the bill, it’s very unfortunate that the bill was rushed through Parliament with such haste.
After all, soon, for anyone suspected of copyright infringement, Techdirt will look like this. At that point, continuing such discussions online will be slightly more difficult.
Permalink | Comments | Email This Story

The Bugzilla Project is announcing that Bugzilla 3.6 has been released and is now available for install or upgrade. With Bugzilla 3.6, the development team focused on improving the existing components and features, but it also comes with a few big, new features. Notable is the new extensions system that enables developers to quickly build new functionality on top of the ex… (
Google has just launched its greatly revamped Google Docs with completely new underpinnings, new document and spreadsheet editors and the brand-new drawing editor. This last tool is clearly aimed at the work and school environments and is designed to allow several people to collaborate on flow charts, project plans, diagrams and any other kind of graphics you&rsqu… (


Despite the recent troubles, it’s still a pretty great time to build a service based on or catering to Twitter. A great example of this is bit.ly, Twitter’s ‘official’ URL shortener. The service just keeps on growing and posted record numbers again in March. And the service is about to get even better… (
Now that the Google Buzz hype and controversy have died down, it’s probably the best time to find out if it has what it takes to become a popular social web product. It would be Google’s first if it did. Any social web service, especially one focused on sharing as much as Buzz, needs to make it easy for sites to add sharing options for it. Two mont… (
Facebook has reached a stage where it can pursue any product or feature it wants and enter pretty much any market as a strong competitor. Google is one of the few other companies in this position and Facebook has only recently become so powerful. It’s not wasting any time, though, and it is looking at various opportunities. One of these is the Q&A… (