Suncor Energy Inc. has been on fire lately, but for all the wrong reasons.
Yesterday, the country's largest energy company had another fire at its oil sands operations, its third in five months. Analysts were not impressed, with some now questioning the company's reliability.
"We have become increasingly concerned about [Suncor's] execution performance," Greg Pardy, analyst with RBC Capital Markets, said in a note Wednesday.
Expecting four weeks of repairs, Mr. Pardy has trimmed his 2010 synthetic oil production forecast to 284,000 barrels a day, down 3.4%, while raising expected cash costs 4% to $38 a barrel.
He's also downgraded Suncor to Sector Perform, and cut his target price 6% to $46.
"It is never easy to downgrade a stock once most of the bad news appears to be reflected in its valuation, but Suncor may trade in a sideways range in coming months pending improved oil sands operating performance and execution in general," he said.
Meanwhile Andrew Potter, analyst with UBS, maintains a Buy rating and $47 price target, noting the fire does not have any material impact on asset value but it does freeze any operational momentum Suncor had built up through 2009.